Is Obama a Marxist?

No.
That is the short answer to the question.
Whenever a politician deeply angers the American right wing, I start to really like that particular politician. They must be doing something right.
Plenty of Glenn Beck addicts, and right winged Americans who seemingly have no idea what Marxism actually is, keep throwing the word MARXIST at Obama. I take great offence at this, because I quite like Marx. I also quite like Che Guevara.
I quite like Marxism, I quite like Bakunin too. And Obama is quite the opposite. And here’s why.

He isn’t forcing business to meet production quotas.

Those same businesses that aren’t forced to meet production quotas are also not run by the workers.

He has never called for a mass workers revolution.

Nor are the above three points ever going to happen.

Left wing, does not mean Marxist.

Government interference in some aspects of the economy, in order to prop up demand during capitalist busts, are not Marxist. In fact, they are Keynesian. Which again, is not Marxism. The World is not as black and white as the right wing likes to make out. The choice isn’t Reagan, or Marx.

A Marxist would not put ex-bankers in his Treasury.

Actually, A Marxist wouldn’t have a treasury, because a Marxist wouldn’t be in power, because power wouldn’t exist.

Regulation on amoral industry to stop it becoming immoral industry, is not Marxist.

Keynes was not a Marxist.

Safety nets like Social Security, are not Marxist.

There is no democratic control of the means of production.

Wages exist.

Your State and National borders exist.

Government programs paid for by taxpayers are not Marxist because A) Money would be abolished under true Marxism, and B) Government wouldn’t exist under true Marxism, because Marxism is pretty close to what Bakunin and Kroptkin advocated.

Being black, and friends with Muslims, does not make him a Marxist terrorist who hates White people.

Nor does it make it so, if Glenn Beck says it.

Obama is President. Head of a Government. A Nation State. The very concept of a President, Government and State is anti-Marxist.

In fact, any kind of government regulation set by the State from Minimum wage to Medicare, runs contrary to Marxism, because it legitimises the State.

No industry is Nationalised (unless you count the police force and fire department as industries, by most Right Winged Americans tend to over look those).

And before you say it, Healthcare in the U.S is not Nationalised.

Ask your local supermarket chain if they’re making a profit. If they are, then Marxism has not come to America.

Being Atheist, does not make one a Marxist. (Obama’s religious beliefs are irrelevant).

Obama has never tried to suggest that private property be abolished, that division caused by the free flow of capital is the root of all evil, and all means of productions be taken over by a workers revolution. Until he does, he in no way can be considered Marxist.

The Founding Fathers were neither Socialist nor neoliberalist proponents, because they did not know what Socialism and Neoliberalism were. Are you a proponent or exponent of Chrositographicness? You’re neither, because you don’t know what it is, neither do I, I just made it up. Similarly, the words Neoliberalism and Socialism would have made no sense to the Founders. Stop trying to manipulate their words to suit your agenda.

Higher taxes on the rich, does not mean Marxism. In fact, Marx never mentions the concept.

Just because Obama hung around with members of Socialist and Communist parties in his college days, does not mean he wishes to turn America into the USSA. It’s like saying, he was friends with a few posh British people, and so that clearly means he wishes to revoke independence and become a colony of the British again.

A society that uses welfare to further perpetuate the division between employer and employee, is not Marxist.

Obama is further to the right than Britain’s Liberal Democrats, who are centre-left. He is further right than the Swedes. Both the Lib Dems and the Swedes are not Marxists. The entire World other than crazed right winged Americans understand this. In fact, Swedish healthcare, EVIL MARXIST healthcare, ranks close to the top of the World rankings. America’s system, well, let’s just say it’s fucking appalling. Swedish education, including higher education is free for all, and they still have a higher rate of social mobility than the U.S. EVIL MARXISTS!!!

If we were to look at the politics of, say, Conservative hero Disraeli, we see that actually, by todays standards, Disraeli is more ‘Socialist’ than Obama could ever hope to be. Obama is a one nation conservative of old.

The ‘hike’ in the top rate of tax by the Obama administration for 2013 to 36.9% is not at all a tax hike, and just a rise from the Bush era. Between 1993, and 2000 (also known as the boom years), the top rate of tax was …. 39.6%… exactly as the President has proposed for 2013. By mad Republican standards, every President has been a mad Socialist. Except for Bush. Reagan would certainly fall into the category of ‘Marxist’ by 21st Century Republican standards.

George Orwell’s 1984 does not represent a Marxist style of government. It was a critique on the misuse of Marxism for totalitarian gain. It is an Authoritarian government; Stalinist, if you will. The whole point was to critique Stalin. Orwell was a Marxist. 1984 was not Marxism. Saying “it’s like 1984!!” when speaking of Obama is nonsense and then saying he’s a Marxist, is incompatible. You do not have a telescreen in your house. You do not have a number assigned to you by the single ruling party. You do not have to work changing history for the government owned media, and your kids do not report you to the thoughtpolice who then do not go on to torture you into submission. Therefore, stop using the phrase “big brother society”, your scare tactics wont work.

Obama is not, never has been, and never will be a Marxist.

About these ads